Final software choice for my usage

-
Without being too critical of Zoneminder, I will just summarize that Blue Iris is for me.  I have finished installing 18 cameras in and around my home and the best way for me to tune the performance of these cameras was by utilizing the myriad of settings within the Windows based Blue Iris software.

For my purposes, I found nothing that Blue Iris couldn't do for me and there were many things with Zoneminder which were confusing at best.  I wish I could keep going with both solutions during my motion tuning phase, but the fact is with Blue Iris very tightly tuned on 18 cameras I am using approximately 45-60% CPU continuously on the VM Host.  I have assigned all 4 cores of my i7-7700 4.2GHz processor to the Windows machine and have nothing left for Linux.  Sorry Linus.

In some respects this is disappointing, but I think it proves the point very well.  If you like using a Graphical User Interface (GUI) and are comfortable with Windows - don't even worry what you are missing by going with the Open Source NVR software.  As far as I can tell you are not missing anything and gaining a lot.  I'm open to feedback on this statement because I honestly didn't get down to the real nuts and bolts - I'm anxious to hear what Zoneminder users feel Blue Iris doesn't do for them.

Please stand by for my final blog post on Prosumer Video Surveillance where I will show how the entire system has been designed, built and how I tuned it.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blue Iris Initial Performance Testing

-
Image
Initial performance testing with Blue Iris NVR running on Windows 10 Pro. I'll admit, I did some initial testing of Blue Iris on another machine and experienced some significant performance challenges especially when recording continuously from multiple cameras.  It appeared that more than just a couple 3 megapixel cameras recording at one time would eat up most of the CPU even on a very powerful machine.  This is the reason for me wanting to do more extensive testing of Blue Iris and other NVR software. Please keep in mind, my soon-to-be-replaced off-the-shelf Amcrest DVR supporting 8 - 1080p cameras is recording every camera in full resolution 24/7 and it runs very, very cool.  It can't be even 1/4 the power of the Core i7 system I just built.  This tells me either the video stream coming from the IP cameras is more intensive, the Windows operating system is creating too much overhead, or the Blue Iris software is just inefficient.  I need to get to the bottom of this.
Read more

NVR Testing Platform

-
The NVR hardware is assembled and now it is time to get the operating system(s) installed.   I grappled with dual boot versus running multiple OS’s virtually.  Given my experience with VMWare and the desire to keep systems running in parallel for testing I have opted to virtualize.  I’ll be using the free VMWare ESXi platform ... well, because it is free and it’s really, really good.  There is one limitation that may keep me from continuing to run this virtualization environment long term, specifically the limitation of 2 CPUs per guest machine.  The Core i7 processor has 4 cores and I will want all of them assigned to my final system.  Other than that, I would actually prefer to run even 1 OS on VMWare because of the tools available - some I will explain later. Learn more about virtualization basics.   Learn more about installing the ESXi hypervisor.   Installing VMWare ESXi:    Visit VMWare’s site to download the ESXi ISO for free, use Rufus to create a bootable USB thumb
Read more

Installation: Blue Iris versus ZoneMinder

-
Image
Overview Although this post is not intended to be an instruction manual for installing these two NVR software programs, I do step through the processes and link to step-by-step instructions.  The true intention is to give you a window into my experience setting up both systems up to the point of streaming a camera. My skill level Since I'm installing on operating systems where I have different skill levels, you should know where I stand on each.  I want this evaluation to be as fair as possible, but I can't alter my knowledge of one system in such a short time-frame - so we just have to deal with and acknowledge the difference: Windows:   Intermediate.   At one time I knew much more than I do today, but hey, Windows is easy, and for the purposes of installing Blue Iris, I rarely, if ever, had to dig into my Intermediate skill bag. Linux: Rusty Novice.   As with Windows, I used to know more than I do now.  The difference is, for installing ZoneMinder I definitely
Read more